Episode 287 - Managing Your Editorial Crew with Roz Morris
Are you getting value from the podcast? Consider supporting me on Patreon or through Buy Me a Coffee!
Amazon Music | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast | Castbox | Pocket Casts | Podbean | Player FM | TuneIn | YouTube
Roz Morris discusses MANAGING YOUR EDITORIAL CREW, including how authors can effectively manage their editing process, the role beta readers play in the development of an author's work, what the needs are for editing before submitting a work to a traditional publisher or an agent, and tips for indie authors on making the most out of their editing experiences and dollars.
Roz Morris’s novels and memoir have been recognized by major mainstream awards. She’s coached award-winning writers in both fiction and non-fiction, taught creative writing for The Guardian masterclasses, blogged for Writers & Artists Yearbook, and been a regular judge on Litopia’s Pop-Up Submissions show, critiquing manuscripts from promising writers. Roz is also the Editor-in-Chief of the Alliance of Independent Authors.
Episode Links
https://nailyournovel.wordpress.com/
Episode 247 - Newsletter Marketing as a Creative Endeavor with Roz Morris
Episode 088 - How to Receive and Give Critique with Tiffany Yates Martin
Summary
This week on The Indy Author Podcast, Matty Dalrymple talks with Roz Morris about the evolution of authors' editing needs as their careers progress. They dive into the different types of editing, provide insights into how authors can effectively manage their editing process, and explore the role beta readers play in the development of an author's work. This podcast episode highlights the changing landscape of editing and provides tips for indie authors on making the most out of their editing experiences.
Roz Morris begins by outlining the three general categories of editing: developmental editing, copy editing, and proofreading. Developmental editing focuses on the content of a manuscript, ensuring that it works for its intended audience and fulfills its potential. Following that is copy editing, where inconsistencies and inaccuracies are addressed. The final stage is proofreading, which checks for any remaining minor errors, making the book ready for publication.
Matty explains her approach to editing, describing how she uses a single editor for her novels to identify major issues, focusing primarily on the character's motivations. Additionally, she relies on beta readers to provide insights and feedback that go beyond what's typically covered in a traditional edit. This tailored method has evolved over time, informed by her growing expertise, a network of sophisticated beta readers, and the advancement of editorial tools like Microsoft Word.
Roz discusses the change in editing needs that occurs as authors become more experienced. Early on, comprehensive developmental editing may be essential. However, as authors grow more proficient, they learn what to watch for in their own work and can rely more on beta readers and targeted editorial feedback to address their "blind spots." Roz explains how seasoned writers often transition away from needing extensive developmental edits unless they venture into unfamiliar genres or styles.
A significant point made by both Matty and Roz is the importance of having a network of beta readers that are knowledgeable about the author's specific genre. Beta readers not only help identify issues but can also provide market research by giving feedback on characters, plot elements, and story satisfaction. They caution, however, that authors should carefully weigh beta readers' suggestions and maintain their vision for their work.
Matty shares an anecdote where her editor suggested a change that led her to think deeper about setting and plot possibilities, ultimately enriching the story. Roz emphasizes that effective editors engage in discussions with authors, offering guidance rather than dictating changes. This collaborative process helps authors refine their craft and produce work that aligns with both their artistic vision and market expectations.
Roz and Matty agree that as writers become more practiced, they can better judge what feedback is useful and where they need external help. Matty notes a sophisticated use of tools like AI for organizing thoughts and reaching clarity on plot points before seeking external input.
The conversation shifts towards leveraging beta readers and editors according to their strengths. Matty reveals how she strategically positions her editor within her editing process, taking advantage of different individuals' expertise. They discuss the valuable role that contests with editorial feedback can play in providing impartial insights into one's work.
In the context of traditional publishing, Roz advises against unnecessary copy editing or proofreading before submitting a manuscript, suggesting that the focus should be on developmental improvements instead. The expectation is that publishers and literary agents will undertake their own developmental edits once a manuscript is submitted.
Ending on a reflective note, they discuss when it might be time for an author to seek new editorial relationships. If an author consistently disagrees with their editor’s feedback, it may indicate that they've outgrown that editorial partnership. Roz encourages authors to remain open to collaboration and to continuously assess their editorial needs as they develop their skills and grow their careers.
In summary, this podcast episode provides insightful guidance for indie authors on adapting their editing strategies to match their evolving competencies, highlighting the critical role of both editors and beta readers in an author’s development. It underscores the importance of building a supportive creative team and remaining adaptive in one’s approach to producing compelling, polished narratives.